ScalingRealtor.com
    See how it works

    How to Recruit Top-Producing Agents Without Better Splits or More Leads

    By Sam Spijkerman, Founder, ScalingRealtor.com

    Quick Answer

    Public 2026 industry data and our own client data agree: economics gets an agent's attention first, but support, systems, and growth opportunity are what keep them. Brokerages that can't win on splits can still win by making that other case.

    Every brokerage assumes the agents they want are being won or lost on splits. Real Brokerage's June 2026 Agent Survey of 153 agents found commission economics is the top factor agents name when first evaluating a brokerage, but support, culture, and growth opportunity determine whether they stay. In our own smaller sample collected over the last 3 months, 83% of brokers who described agent frustrations in detail named lack of support, not compensation, as the actual driver.

    A live example of exactly this positioning: a team in Miami's recruiting ad opens by naming the obvious pitch everyone else is making, 100% commission, and immediately disqualifies it, arguing that plan alone has never once closed a deal. The ad reframes the decision entirely, away from the split and onto "the machine," the coaching, systems, and training that actually produce the closings the split gets applied to, backed with specific, named proof rather than vague claims about culture.

    One of our own AR (attraction-based recruiting) principles applies directly here too: position the broker as an educator or resource first, recruiter second. This is a positioning angle we prefer and test, not a claim backed by controlled A/B data yet.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    If I can't offer the best splits in my market, how do I compete?

    Address what agents are actually frustrated about, which is support and growth opportunity more often than compensation.

    Do agents care more about splits or support when deciding to switch?

    Splits get initial attention. Support and growth opportunity determine whether an agent stays.

    What's the fastest way to prove a brokerage's support claims are real?

    Specific, named examples and a documented result, rather than a general statement about "great culture."

    Related Resources

    See the system in action.

    Watch the full breakdown of how we attract producing agents for brokerages like yours.

    Apply Now